Judge allows Maine lobstermen’s lawsuit over ‘red listing’ to advance

PORTLAND PRESS HERALD • February 7, 2025

After almost two years in limbo, a defamation lawsuit Maine lobstering groups filed against a California aquarium can move forward, a federal judge ruled Friday. The Maine Lobsterman’s Association, the Maine Coast Fishermen’s Association and three lobster businesses sued the Monterey Bay Aquarium Foundation in 2023 after the organization’s Seafood Watch program put lobster on a “red list” of seafood consumers should avoid. The Monterey Bay Aquarium Foundation argued that it has a right to make its rating based on Maine’s free speech laws. But Maine lobstermen have said that the red listing not only is false but also has caused significant economic harm to them and the Maine lobster brand.